Thinking of Selling Home: Teenager Reactions Causing Hesitation

We've lived in our home now for 6 years. We moved across country in 2019, and settled into a lovely little town. Kids are all in K-12 school (local and public) which is rare for most places in the United States. Kids are 14-18. Oldest graduated last year. Given COVID and all the headwinds that year, our kids transitioned beautifully.

I want to preface this by saying we love our current home. It has a pool, and is in a great location. It's on just shy of two acres, and resides within an HOA. However, we've always wanted a little more room to roam.

Recently, a "fixer-upper" that was built in the early 90's was listed for sale near us. It's on 8 acres, and has some incredible views. It's also outside an HOA, which I love. I have visions of starting a dog rescue and doing things that an HOA likely won't allow. The land is fairly hilly (less flat acreage), and does not have a pool. It's only a mile away from our current property still within the kids school zone, so the only thing really changing is their address/routine. It's livable now, but it does need some work, likely over time.

We went and looked at the home, and took the kids. Reactions were mostly negative, which surprised me. Here's how they reacted:

Oldest Child: Our oldest lives at home and is attending college locally. She said she'd move out if we moved because she doesn't like the house. She also said she'd hold resentment towards us for selling because she can't fathom someone else living in the home she's lived in all through high school. She pretty much broke down, started crying, etc. Kind of threw me off if I'm being honest. She also said where we live now is where she wants her kids to come back to and remember as their grandparents home.

Middle Teenagers: Our 16 year-olds don't seem to care much. One said "do whatever you think is best." The other was hesitant, but once we told him we'd get some goats, he said he's fine with whatever.

Youngest Teen: Our youngest follows the lead of our oldest. She said she doesn't want to go, and seemed sad, but I think she's at a place where she'd be fine. She starts high school next year, and seems to be upset at losing the pool.

So, I guess I'm just looking for some honest advice. We have a really great relationships with our kids. On one hand, I feel like it's best to not upset the status quo. The move really doesn't change anything for us financially better, or worse, so I don't have a financial justification to say "we need to do this."

On the other hand, I don't want to be short sighted and not take the leap to appease the kids and miss out on something that myself and my wife may love for years/decades to come. The views are astonishing, and it feels like you can see half the state from the front porch.

So, should I be giving more weight to the kids, and just sitting tight because it's easier? Or should I be taking our own happiness/long term goals into account and telling the kiddos to deal with it? Am I being selfish? My wife could swing either way. I feel like we had such a good transition in 2019, that I don't want to upset the balance. At the same time, it feels stupid not to take a swing at something that could be amazing long term.

I welcome any feedback!