Help Settle A Pub Debate: Who Was The Best Player From The Class Of ‘92?

Hi all,

I need your help settling a pub debate about the Class of ’92. We all agree that the likes of Nicky Butt and Phil Neville are near the bottom of the pecking order, but when it comes to ranking the others—Ryan Giggs, Paul Scholes, David Beckham, and Gary Neville—things get getting touchy.

Some of us argued that Scholes was untouchable for his vision and passing, while others said Giggs’ longevity and iconic moments make him the standout. Of course, Beckham’s influence and global stardom can’t be ignored, and Gary Neville’s consistency and leadership give him a case too.

Can the fine folks of this subreddit settle it for me?

To make this more interesting, here are 5 questions to consider when deciding the rankings:

1.  Who had the most complete skill set for their position, considering their role in United’s success?

2.  Whose peak was the highest during their time at United, and how impactful were they in big games?

3.  Which player would you build your team around if they were all at their best?

4.  Who made the biggest contribution to United’s trophy haul over their career?

 5. If you could only bring one of them back to their prime and add them to today’s squad, who would it be and why