Which seller would you choose?

I’m looking to buy a hammered 5 motif bracelet. I posted one yesterday that was not a great rep. The reason I want hammered over guilloché is because of my lifestyle - ideally I’d like to wear this piece 24/7 and I’m worried I’d destroy a guilloché over time. A couple of comments yesterday stated that no one has been able to accurately rep the hammered motif. So my question is, based on these pics would you choose MC or Funny? Or would you skip it all together?

For the video, 1st is Funny, 2nd is MC. I should also note that MC does not recommend hammered because she doesn’t consider it perfect.