Lattafa Fakhar Rose or Zimaya Magma Love?

As the title says, I’m a bit stuck with what to go with.

They seem really similar, although magma love is 3/4 of the price and not very known?

Please help me decide 😁

edit: here are the notes for each

Zimaya Magma Love

TOP NOTE
Fruity - Pomegranate - Lily -  Saffron

MID NOTE
Tuberose - Jasmine - Gardenia - Vanilla - Amberwood

BASE NOTE
Gardenia - Ambroxan - Musk - Rose - Peony

Fakhar Rose

TOP NOTE
Aldehyde - Lily - Pomegranate - Fruit - Orange Blossom

MID NOTE
Rose - Jasmine - Gardenia - Tuberose

BASE NOTE
Vanilla - Sandalwood - Ambroxan - White Musk - Vetiver - Patchouli