Help me choose a size!

I think the Diamond on the left is a little too small but does the one on the right seem TOO big? I like big so I don’t mind it being an eye catcher but don’t want anything outrageous.

Posting stats of both later but wanted some objective opinion on appearance alone.

I think the Diamond on the left is a little too small but does the one on the right seem TOO big? I like big so I don’t mind it being an eye catcher but don’t want anything outrageous.

Posting stats of both later but wanted some objective opinion on appearance alone.